Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 18 MARCH 2019

Ontario Court Rejects Well Established Rules For Interpreting Insurance Policy Exclusions

In Pembridge Insurance Company of Canada v Chu, a judge of Ontario's Superior Court of Justice recently concluded that insurance policies ought to be interpreted differently when multiple insurers are involved.

CanadaInsurance

In Pembridge Insurance Company of Canada v Chu,1 a judge of Ontario's Superior Court of Justice recently concluded that insurance policies ought to be interpreted differently when multiple insurers are involved. In this problematic decision, the court deviated from the long-standing rule that exclusion clauses should be interpreted "narrowly". Remarkably, the court began with the assumption that one of the insurance policies must respond to the loss. Based on this assumption, the court decided that different rules of contractual interpretation would apply.

This case is problematic because (i) it conflicts with the well-established rules for policy interpretation; (ii) it suggests that a policy can be interpreted by looking outside the contract to its effect on a non-party; and (iii) the assumption that one policy must indemnify the insured was both irrelevant and an improper consideration on a duty to defend application. Absent appellate guidance, this decision may

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from