The Ontario Superior Court of Justice recently upheld the
Lawyers Professional Indemnity Co.'s ("LawPRO")
denial of coverage for a practicing lawyer because the claims
against the lawyer in question arose from investment advice he had
given prior to providing professional advice.1 The court
looked at "extrinsic evidence", that it was permitted to
consider by the terms of the Policy itself, and agreed with LawPRO
that the lawyer's investment advice was not a "direct
consequence" of any prior professional services. Accordingly,
the Investment Advice Exclusion set out below applied and coverage
was properly denied and there was no duty to defend the
insured.
This decision is yet another reminder to lawyers that they
should be extremely wary of providing any advice or services to
their clients that could be construed as "investment advice
and/or services."