Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 21 NOVEMBER 2016

Heiner v. Pasha Et Al.: Claiming Diminished Value Under Ontario's OAP1 Auto Policy – Redux

Miller Thomson
Miller Thomson
Contributor

Miller Thomson

Miller Thomson LLP ("Miller Thomson") is a national business law firm with approximately 500...

View firm profile
Explore more from Miller Thomson

We recently blogged about the Small Claims Court decision in Renwick v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada.

CanadaInsurance

We recently blogged about the Small Claims Court decision in Renwick v. Allstate Insurance Company of Canada.1 The case dealt with an insurer's motion to dismiss a lawsuit on the basis that an insured's claim for "diminished value"2 under an OAP1 Policy had no merit. The court's refusal to grant the motion and dismiss the action before trial left the impression that an insured's claim for diminished value under an OAP1 Policy is a possibility in Ontario. The unreported decision in Heiner v. Pasha et al.3 determines the issue of indemnity for diminished value more definitively4.

Background

The Plaintiff, Andrea Heiner, claimed compensation against various defendants arising from damage caused to her vehicle following its involvement in a collision in which Heiner was not at fault. Heiner sued both the owner and driver of the at fault vehicle that struck hers, and her own automobile insurer (Desjardins Group). The action proceeded to trial and was heard over two

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from