Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 12 DECEMBER 2014

"Good, Better, Best": The Meaning of "Best-Efforts" in Answering Undertakings

In Linamar Transportation Ltd. v. Johnson ( 2014 ONSC 4415), the Ontario Superior Court and Divisional Court were called upon to consider the meaning of "best-efforts" in the context of the obligation to answer undertakings given on examination for discovery.

CanadaInsurance

In Linamar Transportation Ltd. v. Johnson ( 2014 ONSC 4415), the Ontario Superior Court and Divisional Court were called upon to consider the meaning of "best-efforts" in the context of the obligation to answer undertakings given on examination for discovery.

In Linamar, the undertakings given by one of the parties went unanswered for almost two years after the completion of examinations for discovery. The plaintiff made every effort to encourage the delinquent defendant to answer the undertakings without success. It wrote repeated letters requesting productions, arranged for a court-ordered timetable to be implemented and consented to varying the timetable to offer the defendant eight additional months to discharge his obligations. Even after bringing a motion to strike the defence for failure to answer undertakings, the plaintiff consented to multiple adjournments of the motion to give the defendant more time to comply. All of this was to no avail.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from