Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 21 FEBRUARY 2023

Fraud Vitiates Insured's Action Against Insurer Under Automobile Policy

Abbas v Esurance Insurance Company of Canada stablishes a bright-line rule under section 554(1) of the Alberta Insurance Act.

CanadaInsurance

Introduction

Abbas v Esurance Insurance Company of Canada1 establishes a bright-line rule under section 554(1) of the Alberta Insurance Act (the "Act"). The Alberta Court of Appeal found that to deter insureds from making willfully false statements in support of a claim, the giving of a fraudulent statement in respect of one claim bars the insured from recovering for any other claim arising out of the same underlying event. The insured, Mr. Abbas, forfeited both his claims arising from the same event and insurance policy, when he willfully made false statements in support of one of the claims. The court noted that although its ruling might seem draconian, taking a strong stand on this issue was necessary to deter fraudulent claims and to ensure respect for the duties of good faith an insurer and insured owe each other.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from