Markham (City) v. AIG Insurance Company of
Canada, 2020 ONCA 239
The Ontario Court of Appeal recently addressed three important
elements of the duty to defend, where there is concurrent coverage
under two policies: whether there was a concurrent duty to defend
given the existence of an "other insurance" clause, the
obligation to pay ongoing costs and its allocation, and the right
to participate in the defence.
A boy was injured when a puck struck him in the face at a City
owned and maintained arena. The City had rented the rink to a
hockey club and two hockey associations ("Waxers"). The
rental agreement stated that Waxers assumed "all liabilities
and costs for damages caused directly or indirectly by the licensee
or invitees while on or using the facility." Hockey Canada
("HCan") was involved in the oversight of Canadian hockey
programs, but denied having operational control over the arena or
events. The plaintiff sued the City and HCan, and the City
commenced a