The Ontario Superior Court of Justice recently held that an
additional insured was covered by a policy, where there was no
direct claim against the named insured, even though the coverage
was limited to claims arising from the negligence of the named
insured.1 The most common additional insured
endorsements are generally speaking very restrictive in their
application. As this case demonstrates, such an endorsement may
still provide protection to an additional insured even where the
plaintiff has no direct claim against the named insured.
The plaintiff hired Davis Systems of North Bay Nipissing
("Davis Systems") to repair damage to a hotel that was
caused by a fire. Davis Systems in turn subcontracted that work to
Crystal Clean Carpet & Upholstery Specialist ("Crystal
Clean"). Crystal Clean allegedly left a window open in the
middle of winter, causing the pipes to freeze and burst.