In the recent case of McDonald v. Insurance Corporation of
British Columbia, 2012 BCSC 283, the British Columbia Supreme
Court reiterated that breaching a duty of good faith does not
require malicious intent; failure to conduct an adequate
investigation, provide an objective assessment of coverage and
clearly communicate the coverage decision and its effect on the
insured can suffice.
Factual Background
Eleanor McDonald struck a van while driving the wrong way on a
one way street and was thereafter charged with failing to provide a
breath sample, impaired driving and dangerous driving. The driver
of the van she struck commenced an action against McDonald but her
insurer, ICBC, did not appoint counsel for her nor file a statutory
third party notice adding itself as a party to the action. Rather,
the insurer's claims handler performed a cursory investigation
into coverage and largely relied on the criminal proceedings to
provide evidence that McDonald was in breach