Introduction
Recently, in Stewart v. Lloyd's
Underwriters, 2019 BCSC 1582, the British Columbia Supreme
Court considered a claim for punitive damages arising from the
insurer's alleged breach of its duty of good faith. Ultimately,
the court agreed that punitive damages were warranted and made an
award in the amount of $100,000. While far from the $1 million
punitive damages awarded in the leading case of Whiten v.
Pilot Insurance Co. 2002 SCC 18, the court's award is
the largest in BC since Whiten.
Details of the Case
On May 31, 2015, the plaintiff, Christopher Stewart, was on
vacation in Reno, Nevada. While sitting at a bar he suffered a
brief loss of consciousness, fell to the floor and hit his neck. He
was hospitalized for 12 days, had a pacemaker inserted and
underwent surgery to his spine to correct a slippage of a vertebra.
The health care bills from his hospitalization amounted to
$293,127.60 USD.