On April 11, 2013, the Ontario Superior Court dismissed a
$150-million claim for damages by three former medical residents
against the University of Ottawa.1 The students alleged
that the University had improperly evaluated their academic
performance, resulting in their dismissal from the program or a
period of remediation or probation. The court ruled that the action
was an abuse of process.
The AlGhaithy decision affirms that courts have the
discretion to dismiss lawsuits that indirectly attempt to challenge
academic decisions, and clarifies the Court of Appeal's
judgments on this issue.
The facts
Drs. AlGhaithy, Aba-Alkhail and Alsaigh were medical residents
in the neurosurgery or cardiac surgery programs at the University
of Ottawa. Drs. Aba-Alkhail and Alsaigh had academic difficulties
and were required to complete a period of remediation or probation.
Dr. AlGhaithy was dismissed from the University for failing to meet
the Faculty of Medicine's standard