Introduction
For the second time in six months, an Alberta judge ruled that Treaty rights of First Nations must be considered before approving a referendum on Alberta’s independence.
In Chief Electoral Officer of Alberta v Sylvestre (“Sylvestre”)1, issued December 5, 2025, the Court found that the proposed referendum, which asked whether Alberta should become a sovereign, independent country, contravened the Charter and historic treaties between Canada and certain Alberta First Nations.
Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation v Alberta (Chief Electoral Officer) (“Athabasca”)2, issued May 13, 2026, set aside the approval of a referendum on substantially the same question. The Court found, among other things, that the Treaty First Nations were owed a duty to consult before the referendum could proceed3.