On October 11, 2018, the Supreme Court of Canada handed down a
7-2 decision, ruling that Canada's federal lawmakers do
not have a duty to consult with Indigenous peoples
before tabling legislation in Parliament that may affect Aboriginal
and treaty rights. The case was brought before Canada's highest
court by Alberta's Mikisew Cree First Nation ("MCFN")
and stems from the First Nation not being consulted with respect to
two pieces of omnibus legislation that were introduced into
Parliament by the Harper government in the spring of 2012, which
had significant effects on Canada's environmental protection
regime. We first wrote about this appeal here.
Earlier Decisions
The MCFN applied to the Federal Court for judicial review,
arguing that the Crown had a duty to consult with it on the
development of that legislation, since it had the potential to
adversely affect their treaty rights to hunt, fish and trap. In an
unprecedented ruling, the reviewing judge found that