In Bisquip Leasing Corporation v Coco Paving
Inc, Bisquip Leasing Corporation ["Bishop"]
brought a motion for summary judgment against Coco Paving Inc.
["Coco"] for unpaid invoices on various projects. Coco
asserted a counterclaim against Bishop arising out of
"deficient work" and an incident in which a gas line was
allegedly struck by Bishop during excavation.
In opposing the motion for summary judgment, Coco argued that
its claim for equitable set-off barred the claim for summary
judgment and that s. 12 of the Construction Act,
R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30 expressly permitted Coco to withhold the funds
at issue.
More significantly, relying on the established jurisprudence
around summary judgements, Coco submitted that partial summary
judgment should not be ordered unless the claim and the
counterclaim could be readily bifurcated. Coco argued here that the
issues are "so closely connected" that it would be
manifestly unjust to allow for summary judgement. Finally,