After a 5-week trial in the Ontario Superior Court case of
Baker v. Blue Cross, a Toronto jury on June 24,
2022 granted the largest punitive damage award on record to an
individual plaintiff in Canada of $1.5 million in punitive damages.
In addition, reinstatement of LTD benefits and $40,000 in
aggravated damages for mental distress was awarded to Ms.
Baker.
Happily, as it turns out for Sara Baker, Blue Cross blocked her
motion to strike the jury notice and have her case determined by a
Judge alone. Ms. Baker sought the same given court delays caused by
the pandemic. In arguing against the motion, Blue Cross argued that
a jury trial was essential to its "strategy for the
defence of this action" based on "the
surveillance reports and videotapes", which ended up
being irrelevant as it did not show Ms. Baker engaged in any
activities inconsistent with her injury symptoms. Such surveillance
involved 375 hours of covert surveillance.