An Ontario court recently came down hard on an
employer that attempted to terminate an employee for cause without
sufficient justification for doing so. The termination and the
employer's actions related to the termination resulted in a
criminal trial and a chain of events that led to the destruction of
the employee's reputation, and, accordingly to the employee,
his marriage. The trial judge initially awarded the employee
$25,000 in punitive damages and aggravated damages of $75,000. The
employee appealed the punitive damages award and a new trial was
ordered. The trial judge then increased the award for punitive
damages significantly, to $550,000.
Background
The employee in this case, John Gordon Pate, was terminated for
cause from his position as the Chief Building Official for the
Township of Galway and Cavendish. He had been employed by the
Township for approximately 10 years before being terminated. The
basis for the termination was related to permit fees