Employers consistently face the same question: when must we allow an employee to work from home as an accommodation?
Recent decisions do not provide a simple answer. They do, however, send a consistent message. Remote work is no longer unusual. It is now a mainstream option that employers are expected to consider.
That said, it is not automatic. The obligation depends on the evidence, the role, and the process followed.
Preference Is Not Enough
The core principle in accommodation cases has not changed: employers are not required to provide an employee’s preferred accommodation. They must provide a reasonable one.
This remains the strongest employer-side protection. Decision-makers continue to reject work-from-home requests where the evidence shows the employee is seeking a preference rather than establishing its necessity. To that point, in Yue v Bank of Montreal, 2014 CanLII 35910, a request to work remotely full-time was denied where the medical evidence did not establish a