Supreme Court of Canada releases decision in McCormick v.
Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP, 2014 SCC 39
On May 22, 2014, the Supreme Court of Canada (the
"Court") found that Mr. McCormick, a partner with an
ownership stake in a law firm, was not an employee of the law firm,
and therefore not protected by the BC Human Rights Code
(the "Code"). The Court directed human rights
tribunals to focus their analysis on "control and
dependency" in determining whether an employment relationship
exists. The Court does not preclude the possibility that an
individual may be both a partner in a partnership, and an employee
of that partnership for the purposes of the Code. However,
that finding was not appropriate based on the factual context in
McCormick. The decision is another example of the Court
favouring a contextual approach that assesses the substance of a
relationship, rather than its formal legal structure. In adopting
that contextual approach, the Court continues to show a