A recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision serves to remind
employers that the presumption of provincial jurisdiction over
labour relations will only be displaced in the clearest of
cases.
In Ramkey Communications Inc. v.
Labourers' International Union of North America,
the employer opposed certification of a trade union to represent a
provincially regulated bargaining unit of construction employees.
It argued that its "construction technicians" performed
essential work for federally regulated telecommunications companies
and so its labour relations should be federally regulated as
well.
If Ramkey's argument had been successful, the union's
application before the Ontario Labour Relations Board (the
"Board") would have been dismissed, and the union would
have been obliged to seek certification under the Canada
Labour Code (the "Code") instead. Unlike
Ontario's Labour Relations Act, the Code has
no card-check certification process for construction