The Nova Scotia Supreme Court in Matthews v. Ocean
Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2017 NSSC 16 (with supplemental reasons
at 2017 NSSC 123) recently set out the test in Nova Scotia for
determining whether an employee dismissed without cause is entitled
to damages for lost future bonuses. The key consideration, not
surprisingly, is the employee's contract. As such, employers
need to consider the lessons from this case prior to any new
employment relationship in which a bonus forms an integral part of
the employee's contract.
The Facts
The employee, Mr. Matthews, was a chemist who started working
for a predecessor of Ocean Nutrition Canada Limited
("ONC") in 1997. In 2007, Mr. Matthews and ONC signed an
Executive Incentive Agreement, referred to internally as the
Long-term Incentive Program ("LTIP"). Under the LTIP, Mr.
Matthews was entitled to a sizable payout in the event of a sale of
ONC. Also, Mr. Matthews was a participant in ONC's Short-Term
Incentive Program