2012 featured a number of interesting developments in U.S.
public M&A practice that are likely to influence Canadian
boards and public Canadian M&A practice in 2013.
In early 2012, the Delaware Chancery Court issued its decision
in the Kinder Morgan/El Paso merger. As is not uncommon, the
announcement of this merger drew prompt litigation from the
plaintiff's bar, who challenged a number of the decisions made
by the board of El Paso and sought a preliminary injunction to
enjoin the merger despite the high premium offer made by Kinder
Morgan.
Prior Delaware court decisions, such as in Toys 'R' Us
and Dollar Thrifty, have shown a willingness to defer to the
business judgments made by an independent and properly motivated
board in the heat of a negotiated merger, so long as they were
reasonable and directed to the goal of obtaining the highest value
reasonably attainable. In the immediate case, however, the record
disclosed conflicts faced by (among others) one of El