A market registrant's lack of actual knowledge of the source
of tip or their tipper's relationship to an issuer will not
protect them from liability under the Securities Act,
according to the Ontario Court of Appeal in its recent decision in
Finkelstein v.
Ontario Securities Commission. The appeal court upheld
findings of liability against investment advisers Howard Miller and
Francis Cheng on the basis that both ought reasonably to have known
that their respective tippers stood in a special relationship with
the issuer.
Background
This case arose out of the OSC's administrative proceedings
against five individuals, including Miller and Cheng. It was
alleged that each of the five individuals in the tipping chain
breached the insider trading and insider tipping provisions of the
Securities Act and acted contrary to the public interest
when they recommended to family and friends the purchase of shares
in a reporting issuer, Masonite International Corporation. The