On January 11, 2005, the Competition Tribunal found that Sears Canada Inc. ("Sears") engaged in reviewable conduct under the civil misleading advertising provisions of the Competition Act (the "Act"). This case provides important guidance as to how the Competition Tribunal ("Tribunal") interprets the civil ordinary selling price provisions of the Act. The decision has implications for all retailers and other suppliers that use comparative price advertising. Sears is considering whether to appeal the decision.
In 1999, the Act was amended to include a "two track" approach to misleading advertising by creating a set of civil provisions that would be used in most cases, leaving the criminal provisions for use only in the most egregious cases. The Competition Bureau issued guidelines concerning the civil ordinary selling price provisions. The Sears case was the first opportunity for the Competition Tribunal to interpret the civil ordinary selling price provisions. Sears also attacked the