Can a data subject use GDPR access rights as a tool to trigger
compensation claims?
In its recent judgment in Brillen
Rottler (C-526/24), the European Court of Justice
addressed this question directly, confirming that — in
certain circumstances — even a first access request may be
considered abusive where it is made to create the basis for a
damages claim.
Facts of Case:
- In March 2023, an individual residing in Austria subscribed to
the newsletter of the family run optician company Brillen Rottle
that was available on the company's website, thereby
consenting to the processing of their personal data.
- Thirteen days later, the individual submitted a request for
access under Article 15 of the General Data Protection Regulation
(GDPR). According to Article 15, a data subject has the right to
obtain from the data controller a confirmation as to whether or not
their personal data that concerns them are being processed, and, if
so, the right of access to such data