Summary
The New South Wales Court of Appeal held in Bunnings Group
Limited v CHEP Australia Limited [2011] NSWCA 342 that the use
by Bunnings of CHEP's wooden pallets for the delivery of goods
from its distribution centres to its stores constituted an
intentional dealing with CHEP's lawful property that was
repugnant to its ownership rights, thus being a tort of
conversion.
Refusal by Bunnings to comply with CHEP's lawful demands for
return of its property amounted to unlawful detinue.
Damage was the loss of potential hire revenue.
Facts
In its usual business, Bunnings acquired wooden pallets owned by
CHEP when Bunnings received stock from suppliers. It used these
pallets to display goods on its shop-floors; and to store goods not
immediately required for stock replenishment. On many occasions
Bunning's distribution centres also used some of the pallets
owned by CHEP to transport its own goods to and from its
distribution centres and stores.