Sentinel Countrywide Retail Ltd v PC Emerald (QLD)
Pty Ltd [2015] QSC 348
Under new regulations, tenants may be excused from opening for
trade during the COVID-19 pandemic. When the pandemic is over, can
a lessee be compelled to re-open?
In a recent Queensland case, a landlord sought from the Court a
mandatory injunction that would require the lessee to keep its shop
open for business during the landlord's shopping centre
"trading hours" as provided for in the lease. The Court
had to consider the settled practice of not granting mandatory
injunctions which required persons to carry on a business unless
there were "exceptional circumstances".
Background
In February 2014, the tenant (PC Emerald (QLD) Pty Ltd)
("Tenant") entered into a lease for premises in a
shopping centre known as the Emerald Village Centre
("Centre"). In December 2014, the landlord, (Sentinel
Countrywide Retail Ltd) ("Landlord"), purchased the
Centre. The Tenant's lease was for a term of 7