In an important decision for banks and financial providers, the
New South Wales Supreme Court has confirmed that lenders do not owe
a general duty of care to advise a borrower on the viability of
commercial projects for which the loaned funds will be used. The
decision in Permanent Mortgages Pty Limited v MacFadyen
[2012] NSWSC 130 represents the first clear statement that the
principles in the Privy Council's decision in the UK judgment
in National Commercial Bank (Jamaica) Ltd v Hew and Anor
[2003] apply in New South Wales.
Permanent Mortgages commenced proceedings seeking possession of
a property following the defendant's default under a loan
agreement and mortgage. In her loan application, the defendant had
stated the funds were to be used to refinance a home loan and
construct four units. The units to be constructed by the defendant
had been presold under four unconditional contracts for sale which
were subsequently reviewed and endorsed by Permanent Mortgages.