It's not unusual for clients to ask me - "When is
the best time to try and settle this dispute?" "Should we
try early or wait until after the discovery and evidential stages
of litigation"? "Will we look weak if we offer to resolve
the dispute early?"
My experience suggests that the answers to these questions
really depend upon the importance a company places on its
relationship with its opponent, the value it places on preserving
its reputation in the marketplace, the anticipated costs of
protracted litigation, the so called 'prospects of success'
at final hearing and most importantly the ability to break down
what John Lande has termed the 'prison of
fear'.1
All too often we see disputes settled on the "steps of the
court" or in the hallway of the courthouse. The conventional
belief (propagated by some litigators whose interests are not
always conducive to finding a early settlement) is that by
withholding settlement discussions until the last moment we