Trade Marks
Australia
Federal Court Finds Against Mayne Industries Pty Ltd
The Federal Court has found against Mayne Industries Pty Ltd
('Mayne') in their trade mark dispute with
Advanced Engineering Group Pty Ltd ('Advanced
Engineering'). Mayne was the registered owner of a
trade mark consisting of a rod bent to an S shape registered in
relation to 'fence droppers'. Mayne alleged
that Advanced Engineering had infringed their trade mark by
importing 'fence droppers' which embodied the
same shape depicted in Mayne's mark. Advanced
Engineering contended that the shape mark served a
substantially functional purpose and therefore its use of the
shape was not use as a trade mark. The Federal Court agreed
with Advanced Engineering's contention, finding that
the functional features of the S shape meant its use of the
shape was not use as a trade mark. Furthermore, the Court found
that the S