JSM Management Pty Ltd v QBE Insurance (Australia) Ltd
[2011] VSC 339
Introduction
In this case, an appeal from the Victorian Civil and
Administrative Tribunal ('VCAT'), Osborne
J of the Supreme Court of Victoria was required to consider the
meaning of phrase 'wear and tear' in an exclusion clause
and a condition requiring the insured to take reasonable
precautions to prevent loss in an industrial special risks policy
issued by QBE.
Background
JSM Management Pty Ltd ('JSM') leased a
trucking depot / warehouse distribution centre to a company
('the Tenant') for a term of five years
commencing in October 2007. Before going into possession, the
Tenant was advised by a representative of JSM that the hardstand at
the premises had a load bearing rating of 40 tonnes and that the
Tenant would not be able to use its container forklift (with a
potential weight of 100 tonnes) on the hardstand because it would
cause it to fail. The Tenant went into occupation prior to