Background
In this controversial first instance decision, His Honour
Justice Croft held that a ruptured fuse (pausing electrical supply)
constituted "Damage" within the meaning of the insurance
policy and therefore responded to the claim by the Insured.
Facts
Mainstream Aquaculture Pty Ltd (Mainstream)
conducted a commercial business of breeding and selling fish. On 26
October 2008 Mainstream experienced a loss of electrical power and
the loss of a stock of fish.
In May 2008, Mainstream purchased a generator to provide
supplementary power to the property in the event of an interruption
to the mains electricity supply. At the time of the accident, the
fuse on the mains supply ruptured (it tripped which caused it to
rupture) and switched power from the mains supply to the generator.
However the generator failed to operate. The fuse was designed to
trip in the case of an abnormal electrical event. Unlike a circuit
breaker, it was not capable of being reset and