Exclusions and limitations have a precise meaning separate to
the scope of cover, according to the High Court's latest
decision on exclusion clauses. The decision in Westport Insurance
Corporation v Gordian Runoff Ltd [2011] HCA 37 gives valuable
guidance on when exclusions and limitations in insurance policies
will – and won't – be allowed to operate
via section 18B of the NSW Insurance Act 1902.
What was the policy?
Gordian Runoff wrote a seven-year Directors & Officers
(D&O) liability run-off policy for FAI. Westport then wrote
excess of loss reinsurance treaties over three layers for Gordian
Runoff. Gordian Runoff asked Westport to expand the reinsurance
cover to include D&O policies written for up to three years.
Did any of the reinsurance treaties cover the FAI policy, which
covered claims made and notified to Gordian within an extended
period of seven years?