British Waterways v Royal and Sun Alliance Insurance
Plc [2012] EWHC 460 (Comm)
Courts cannot seem to agree on how the words "arising out
of" are to be read, particularly in relation to policies of
insurance.
Background
In December 2004, two contractors (a father and son) drowned
when the tractor they were operating plunged into a canal in
southern England. As they were reversing up the towpath to exit the
site, the tractor travelled too close to the edge of the canal when
the bank gave way causing the tractor to topple into the canal.
The contractors were retained by British Waterways
(BW) to trim the hedges along the towpath of the
Kennet and Avon Canal. The Health and Safety Executive
(HSE) took the view that BW had committed an
offence as the practices adopted for the use of tractors on canal
towpaths had not been suitably assessed and were unsafe. BW pleaded
guilty to the offence and was fined. In addition to the HSE
prosecution, the families and estates