In Drew v State of New South Wales [2015] NSWCA 159
(decided on 11 June 2015) three New South Wales Supreme Court
judges have dismissed a school cleaner's appeal against a
finding that she is not entitled to damages after tripping over a
box on a classroom floor.
On 14 November 2005, the plaintiff, Mrs Drew, was an employee of
Menzies Property Services Pty Ltd and sustained knee injuries while
working at Campbelltown School. She sued both the occupier of the
premises, the State of New South Wales and her employer
Menzies.
Before she tripped over, she had walked through the same
carpeted classroom, which was at the time being used to store items
for a school fete, on six occasions. For the first few times, when
she was either carrying a garbage bag or a vacuum cleaner on her
back, she pushed a heavy box lying on the floor slightly to one
side to make a passage. On the last two times, she carried a mop
and bucket. It was on the very last time she tripped on the