In October 2014, we reported on
the case of Mr Toms, who was employed as a ferry master. An
accident occurred for which Mr Toms was at fault. It emerged that
he had consumed marijuana the night before to assist with shoulder
pain. At that time, he had not been expecting to work the next
morning. There was no suggestion that Mr Toms was affected by
marijuana at the time of the accident, nor that marijuana had any
role in the accident. A positive test in these circumstances was a
clear breach of the employer's drug testing policy. Mr Toms was
dismissed as a result of the positive drug test.
Mr Toms claimed unfair dismissal. The Fair Work Commission
(FWC) at first instance agreed the dismissal was
harsh and ordered that he be reinstated. The employer appealed and
the Full Court of the Fair Work Commission (FCFWC)
overturned the decision.