Inspector Batty v Waste Equipment Pty Ltd &
Anor1 concerned a prosecution brought against Waste
Equipment Pty Limited and the sole director of Waste Equipment,
John Cross (Cross), for failing to ensure the
health, safety and welfare at work of all its employees and, in
particular, Timothy Hirst (Hirst), contrary to
section 8(1) of the Occupational Health and Safety Act
2000 (NSW).
Incident
Waste Equipment operated a business fabricating and selling
waste collection bins and waste equipment in a workshop. At the
time of the incident Emile Pacevski (Pacevski) was
heating, cutting and tack-welding the catches on the door at the
rear of a large waste bin using an oxyacetylene cutting device and
an electric welder. The door of the large waste bin was clamped
shut in order to maintain the correct alignment during the fitting
process and so Pacevski could not see Hirst who was behind the door
of the large waste bin. At the same time, Hirst was spray painting
the