This briefing note sets out an overview of the decision in Medibank Private Limited v McClure [2026] FCAFC 38, including key implications for employment, industrial relations and safety practitioners.
Executive Summary
In practice, organisations are increasingly dealing with matters that require proactive or post‑incident reviews, spanning legal, regulatory, governance and risk considerations. Frequently, these reviews are commissioned at board level or CEO level and structured through lawyers, with an expectation that the resulting report will attract legal professional privilege.
Medibank v McClure is a timely reminder that, when assessing privilege, courts will look past labels and engagement structures and focus instead on what an organisation was objectively trying to achieve in commissioning the review.