A little-known rule in NSW sentencing law is quietly shaping outcomes in criminal cases—and in some situations, it can dramatically reduce the amount of time a person spends in prison.
At the centre of it is section 58 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act (CSPA)—a provision that places a cap on how long a person can be imprisoned when multiple sentences are involved in New South Wales.
What is the “5-year rule”?
Section 58 limits the total length of imprisonment a Local Court can impose when someone is already serving a prison sentence.
In simple terms:
If a person is already in custody, the court generally cannot structure a new sentence (whether fully consecutive or partly consecutive) in a way that pushes the total time—from the start of the existing sentence to the end of the new one—beyond 5 years.