Firm Profile > Dentons > Edinburgh, Scotland


Commercial property: Edinburgh and Glasgow Tier 1

Dentons has recently expanded its UK coverage while maintaining its cross-border capabilities and expertise in English law. In recent highlights, the group handled a series of transactions involving shopping centres, UK-wide projects involving cinemas, mixed-use and industrial developments, and the delivery of new PRS housing units across the UK through its specialist housebuilding unit. Also notable is the team's established strength in the retail sector. Gordon Aitken and Simon Etchells jointly lead the department from the Glasgow office; Allan Cairns is a key contact in the Edinburgh office.

Practice head(s):

Gordon Aitken; Simon Etchells

Other key lawyers:

Corporate tax Tier 1

Dentons' tax team in Scotland has specialist skills across the full gamut of issues, including planning and structuring for corporate deals and reorganisations, real estate tax, cross-border M&A tax issues, financial services tax, and tax planning for high net worth individuals. Practice head Gwen Souter sits in Glasgow is especially renowned for her expertise in international taxation and the structuring of M&A transactions, while Lorna McCaa leads on much of the firm's key work.

Practice head(s):

Gwen Souter

Other key lawyers:

Lorna McCaa; Alastair MacLeod


‘The team at Dentons has deep technical knowledge combined with commercial perspective and an ability to convey complex issues to clients.’

‘Lorna McCaa is able to cut through complex technical issues to identify those that really matter to the client.’

‘Easy to get on with. Engaging, direct and pragmatic. No sitting on the fence.’

Key clients

M&G Real Estate

Standard Life Aberdeen plc

Scottish Equity Partners LLP

The PRS REIT plc

J Sainsbury plc

The Edrington Group Limited

John Menzies plc

FreeAgent Holdings Limited

Dalmore Capital Limited

Hurricane Energy plc

Gatehouse Bank

H.M. Government

EU and competition Tier 1

The competition department at Dentons is best known for work on contentious matters including dawn raids, anti-bribery work and modern slavery issues. Michael Dean leads the group from Glasgow and is regularly involved in significant merger control, leniency applications, compliance programmes, vertical supply chain issues and retailing matters. Contentious specialist Catriona Munro has a particularly strong track record in the cartel space, regulatory issues, State aid and private damages claims,  both on the plaintiff and defendant side. Jennifer Marshall left the Edinburgh office to join Highlands and Islands Airport as in-house counsel.

Practice head(s):

Michael Dean

Other key lawyers:

Catriona Munro; David McGowan; Carolyn Burns; Melanie Martin


Dentons fields a very capable competition cartel litigation team with loads of experience.

The sheer width and depth of the legal knowledge and experience within the competition practice, together with its ability to listen and establish all of the facts, enables it to provide comprehensive, well-reasoned, top-quality legal advice.

The competition law team at Dentons has excellent practical experience in its field of law.

Catriona Munro has a cool, calm head combined with a sensible, pragmatic approach.

Michael Dean is extremely knowledgeable and experienced. He is very supportive and pursues his clients’ interests with vigour and passion. He makes himself accessible and is quick to respond to any communication with well-considered advice.

Key clients

Standard Life Aberdeen PLC

British Polythene Industries Ltd (RPC Group plc)

Stagecoach Group PLC

Network Rail

C&C Group PLC

Aggreko PLC

UK Government Department for International Development

Nynas Petroleum

Baxters Food Group Limited

John Menzies PLC

Edinburgh Airport Limited

London Luton Airport Limited

Strathclyde Passenger Transport

AO Retail Ltd

Beaconsfield Footwear (Hotter Shoes)

FW Evans Cycles (in Administration)


The Range

JCT 600 Ltd

Sytner Group Ltd

Aprirose (formerly QHotels)

Moorfields (Administrators for Toys ‘R’ Us – now in liquidation)

Avis Budget Group Inc.

World Fuels Services


Clyde Blowers Capital

Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG)

Environmental Capital Fund/Indigo Pipelines Limited

Department of Education

East of England Co-op Ltd

Edinburgh Woollen Mill

Central England Co-op Limited

Spar UK Limited

Banking and finance Tier 2

Dentons' work is spread between its borrower and lender client base, which includes clients at a national and international level and spans a variety of sectors; the team has also recently focused on growing its lender side work. The practice covers all aspects of banking and finance mandates including fund financings, securitisations, loan portfolio transfers and corporate borrowing. Susan Kelly heads up the UK banking and finance group and Stuart Fitzsimmons leads the Glasgow and Aberdeen practices. James Wilson specialises in property, fund and corporate finance mandates.

Practice head(s):

Susan Kelly; Stuart Fitzsimmons

Other key lawyers:


Susan Kelly has a fantastic reputation in the sector. Her level of experience and expertise is second to none. She is someone who remains calm and is not prone to grandstanding.

One of the key things at Dentons is the efficiency of the service provided. The heavy lifting is taken on by the banking team, not the client.

Key clients


Card Factory

Rothesay Life

Tenaga Nasional Berhad

Bank of Scotland

Close Leasing Limited

Atom Bank

Edrington Group

Commercial litigation Tier 2

Dentons' 'strong' team is well equipped to represent clients in various domestic and cross-border disputes arising from business transactions and shareholder relations. Its expertise also covers insolvency-related matters. The 'very good' Edinburgh-based Tim Edward, Glasgow partner Douglas Blyth and Aberdeen-based Malcolm Gunnyeon are the main contacts. In 2018, Rona Hutchison left the firm to change career and Ewan Easton retired from private practice.

Practice head(s):

Tim Edward; Douglas Blyth; Malcolm Gunnyeon

Other key lawyers:

Gareth Hale


Always listens to the client and provides good balanced advice.

Key clients

DuPont Teijin Films UK

CVR Global

Network Rail

The Official Receiver

LOC Group

Highlands and Islands Enterprise

Rieuneau Avocats



Rangers FC Group

Construction Tier 2

Noted for its broad offering, Dentons receives regular instructions on various contentious and non-contentious construction matters from developers and building contractors alongside transport, infrastructure and energy sector clients. Mark Macaulay heads the 'very good' team. David Scott retired in April 2018.

Practice head(s):

Mark Macaulay

Other key lawyers:

Kirsti Olson


Kirsti Olson is always well prepared and never on the back foot; she is an excellent communicator and fights like a terrier.

Key clients

Official Receiver of Carillion

McLaughlin & Harvey Construction

Network Rail Infrastructure

Galliford Try Construction (UK)

Taylor Wimpey UK

Halcrow Group

M&G Real Estate



Corporate and commercial: Edinburgh and Glasgow Tier 2

The corporate and commercial group at Dentons is especially strong in the food and drink, financial services, industrial and retail sectors, where it acts for clients including C&C and KKR. Brian Moore's team is led out of Edinburgh and advises Scottish clients operating internationally on cross-border transactions and investments. Donald Smith was recently promoted to the partnership, while the group also has a strong bench at senior associate level, including Owen McLennan in Edinburgh and Kimberley Goh in Glasgow.

Practice head(s):

Brian Moore

Other key lawyers:

Iain Sutherland; Derek McCombe; David McGrory; Claire Armstrong; Owen McLennan; Donald Smith; Kimberly Goh


Dentons’ truly diverse team works in a highly collaborative manner to deliver a great client experience.

Iain Sutherland provides excellent partner-led personable no-nonsense advice.

The team provides commercial, dedicated and sensible advice.

Response times are excellent and partner availability is second to none.

Donald Smith delivers outstanding service and really sets the bar in terms of proactive client support.

The strong team is able to pull on UK-wide Dentons expertise where required.

Key clients

Scottish Equity Partners

Clyde Blowers Capital


John Menzies

Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co Partners LLP (KKR)

Stagecoach Group

Edinburgh Woollen Mill Group

FreeAgent Holdings Limited

The Edrington Group Limited

C&C Group

Castle Water

LEBC Holdings

SIMEC Atlantis

Crime: fraud Tier 2

'Delivering great results', Dentons' 'capable and highly experienced' team advises various national and international clients on fraud and embezzlement matters alongside issues pertaining to insolvency and bankruptcy scenarios. 'Hard working and experienced' consul and counter fraud specialist Craig Kennedy heads the team, which lost senior associate and regulatory expert James McMillan to Al Tamimi & Company in August 2018.

Practice head(s):

Craig Kennedy


The team regularly appears in high-profile and complex cases.

The group has particular experience in fraud and other related issues arising from insolvency.’

Craig Kennedy is the kind of lawyer clients under pressure want on their side; he is proactive and gives concise and focused advice.

Key clients

The Edrington Group

CVR Global

Baxters Food Group

Scotch Whisky Auctions


Hunter Boot


Henderson & Jones


Environment Tier 2

Senior associate Pamela Coulthard heads the Scottish environment practice at Dentons, which is experienced in providing regulatory and compliance advice alongside transactional support.

Practice head(s):

Pamela Coulthard

Key clients

Avis Budget Group


European Energy Efficiency Fund (EEEF)

Nynas UK

The Edrington Group

Ho Bee Land

Peel Gas and Oil

Hugh King & Co

Jinmyung FricTech

Intellectual property Tier 2

The TMT team at Dentons is particularly strong in the food and drink and life sciences sectors, and recently made new client gains in the public sector and manufacturing industry. The group handles the full range of IP issues spanning trade mark and patent matters, IP litigation and copyright issues. Practice head Alison Bryce is a key name for non-contentious work including licensing deals, IP acquisitions, investments and joint venture; Ross Nicol also handles the IP aspects of transactions, e-commerce issues and data protection work.

Practice head(s):

Alison Bryce

Other key lawyers:


The team at Dentons is professional, knowledgeable and well regarded with a diverse but well positioned client base.

The individuals are very approachable and down to earth.

Key clients

Finsbury Food Group plc

The Restaurant Group plc

The Edrington Group

Optos plc (part of Nikon)

National Theatre of Scotland

Edinburgh Woollen Mill

Hunter Boot Limited

British Polythene Industries

Global Alliance for Livestock Vaccines

Collins Debden

Investment funds Tier 2

The practice at Dentons regularly advises its blue-chip client roster on issues relating to fund financing, regulatory matters, corporate structures and disputes. The firm has notable expertise in handling corporate and banking structures with fund involvement; it leverages the firm's knowledge of tax, insurance and trust law. Claire Armstrong is based in Edinburgh and leads the Scotland asset management offering.

Practice head(s):

Claire Armstrong

Other key lawyers:

Tim Edward; Owen McLennan


‘The breadth of the team and practice areas and the lawyers’ ability to draw on different skill sets and expertise is fantastic.’

‘The thing that sets Dentons apart is the effort put in to understand clients’ individual businesses and complexities with regular informal meetings. The low staff turnover drives a consistent approach with a deep understanding of the matters at hand.’

‘The finance experts at Dentons are always there at the end of a phone and able to deal with issues in a constructive way.’

Key clients

M&G Real Estate

Gatehouse Bank

Target Global Advisors Limited

Aberdeen Standard Asia Focus PLC




Sigma Capital

Oil and gas Tier 2

Dentons' practice has particular expertise handling decommissioning work through the expertise of Edinburgh-based Kirsti Olson, drilling matters, and contentious mandates. Corporate expert Gordon Hobkirk also contributes to the practice with litigator Malcolm Gunnyeon; both are based in Aberdeen. The Aberdeen team also recently hired senior oil and gas specialist counsel Kenny Paton from Webber Wentzel; he has substantial experience in the North Sea and internationally.

Practice head(s):

Kenny Paton

Key clients

Completion Products

Decom North Sea

DOF Subsea Limited

KCA Deutag Drilling

Safetec UK Limited

Stork TS UK Limited

Projects Tier 2

In the primary projects market, Dentons is noted for its involvement in the hub programme, and has also been active in the secondary market, a key area of strength for Edinburgh-based practice head Euan Wilson. The group has recently advised on numerous investments, divestitures, refinancings and restructurings relating to PFI, PPP, New Product Development (NPD), hub, Building Schools for the Future (BSF) and energy sector projects. Andrew Orr is a key name for project finance work.

Practice head(s):

Euan Wilson

Other key lawyers:

Andrew Orr; Stewart MacIver

Key clients


Dalmore Capital

Sir Robert McAlpine

Aviva Public Private Finance

Network Rail

Infrastructure Managers Limited

Robertson Capital Projects

Green Investment Bank /GIG

Morgan Sindall Investments


Blue Transmission

Envac UK

ISS Mediclean

Lloyds Bank

Transport for London

UPM Kymmene UK

Triple Point

Alpha Real Capital



Strathclyde Partnership for Transport

Choice Housing

Tenaga Nasional Berhad

HM Govt/Official Receiver

Property litigation Tier 2

Dentons handles various contentious matters for institutional landlords and corporate tenants, including contractual and property transaction-related matters, dilapidation and damages claims as well as rent review and lease termination disputes. Team head Gareth Hale is also an accredited mediator.

Practice head(s):

Gareth Hale

Key clients


Aviva Investors


Universities Superannuation Scheme (USS)

Network Rail Infrastructure


TSB Bank

Transport Tier 2

As sole legal advisor to Network Rail, Dentons' strength lies in handling major rail sector infrastructure projects, which includes advice on regulatory, competition law and procurement matters pertaining to franchise and framework agreements. Euan Wilson, who co-heads the practice with construction specialist Mark MacAulay, is the main contact for project finance.

Practice head(s):

Euan Wilson; Mark Macaulay

Other key lawyers:

Barry Edgar; Malcolm Gunnyeon

Key clients

Network Rail

Port of Cairnryan

Traffic Commissioner for Scotland

Strathclyde Partnership for Transport (SPT)

Commercial property: elsewhere in Scotland Tier 3

The Scottish commercial property team at Dentons fields a dedicated housebuilding unit, which advises major clients on project work, strategic options, consortium agreements, joint ventures and site acquisitions. Also notable is the group's strength in the renewable energy space, where practice head David Rose and members of the banking, corporate and real estate departments assist clients with acquisitions and disposals, leasings and joint venture arrangements.

Practice head(s):

David Rose


‘Dentons’ partners are helpful, professional, proactive and reactive where appropriate and necessary.’

‘David Rose is exceptional. He is helpful, patient and diligent in securing a site option agreement, even with a difficult client.’

Key clients

Persimmon Homes Limited

PAL Trustees Limited

RQ Capital Limited

Agile Energy Recovery Limited

Santander UK plc

Bank of Scotland plc

Hughes Electrical Limited

Muirden Energy LLP

Kilmac Properties Limited

Duncan Farms

Barclays Bank UK plc

Debt recovery Tier 3

Dentons provides commercial and compliance advice on volume debt and asset recovery in the debt purchase, banking and asset finance, utilities, oil and gas and general commercial sectors. Litigators Frank Johnstone and Douglas Blyth are the main contacts; Johnstone enjoys an 'excellent reputation in the market'.

Practice head(s):

Frank Johnstone; Douglas Blyth

Key clients

RCI Financial Services

Clydesdale Bank

Link Financial

Shawbrook Bank

Startline Motor Finance

Network Rail Infrastructure

Toyota Financial Services UK

FCA Automotive Services UK



Agricultural Mortgage Corporation

Ison Harrison

Employment Tier 3

Dentons' 'responsive and approachable' team has a strong profile for insolvency-related and corporate employment work, which frequently involves other UK jurisdictions, but the team's expertise also expands to various other HR matters including executive contracts and data protection issues. In litigation, handling equal and holiday pay claims, discrimination and unfair dismissal matters alongside whistleblowing allegations are particular areas of expertise. The 'very professionalMark Hamilton is the main contact for Scotland following Amanda Jones' appointment as the firm's global woman's advancement director in October 2018. The 'very experienced' Alison Weatherhead was appointed counsel in March 2018 and advises on the full spectrum um employment law, while in April 2018, director Alan Delaney moved to Morton Fraser.

Practice head(s):

Mark Hamilton

Other key lawyers:

Key clients

The Official Receiver

Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co Partners

TUI Holidays

Barclays Bank

Menzies Aviation

The Edrington Group

DuPont Teijin Films

W. L. Gore UK

Martin Currie Investment Management

MB Aerospace

Educational Institute of Scotland

Energy (excluding oil and gas) Tier 3

Dentons' 2017 merger with Maclay Murray & Spens LLP expanded its presence in the Scottish market and allowed the Scottish offices to leverage the significant resources of the global network. The group has also grown its client base adding several global clients to its well-established domestic client base; it was recently appointed by the Scottish government to advise on the implementation of its energy efficiency programme. David Cruickshank leads the renewables practice and is a member of the firm's international cross-practice energy transition initiative.

Practice head(s):

David Cruickshank

Other key lawyers:

Allan Cairns; Bill Fowler; Paul Young


The expertise and in-depth industry knowledge Dentons demonstrates is vital to ensuring a smooth and successful transaction. Clients could not commend them highly enough.

Key clients

Aggreko Plc

Blue Transmission

Canadian Solar

Close Brothers

European Energy Efficiency Fund

Green Investment Group

SIMEC Atlantis Energy

Scottish Government

Tenaga Nasional Bhd

Triple Point LLP

IT and telecoms Tier 3

Dentons' Scottish IT practice handles outsourcing matters, system procurements and implementations, e-commerce and data protection advice, and issues pertaining to hosted services. The group also leverages the firm's global network to advise on international matters. Alison Bryce leads the team, which also includes non-contentious IT specialist Ross Nicol and senior associate Julie Brown, who has experience in website compliance and e-commerce issues.

Practice head(s):

Alison Bryce

Other key lawyers:


The group at Dentons is very much part of the combined team, working to achieve a common outcome for the client.

Ross Nicol does a fantastic job both bringing breadth and depth of expertise to an assignment, and working in a flexible manner, with a pragmatic approach, to achieve the best outcome for the client.

Key clients

Sainsbury’s Bank

Menzies Distribution


MUFG Bank Ltd/MUFG Securities EMEA

Finsbury Food Group

Aon UK Limited

PCF Group

Stream Technologies Limited

Media and entertainment Tier 3

Dentons' media and entertainment practice advises broadcasters and organisations in the arts and culture sector on intellectual property matters, copyright infringement, data protection, defamation risks and other contentious issues, such as production rights and censorship. In the non-contentious space, the team drafts agreements for cultural bodies and helps clients with reputation management. Partner Susan Snedden is well known for litigating in IP disputes on behalf of major broadcasters. Practice head Ewan Easton has a track record of advising BBC Scotland on their reporting rights and duties.

Practice head(s):

Ewan Easton

Other key lawyers:

Key clients

BBC Scotland

STV Productions

Edinburgh International Festival

STV Group plc

National Theatre for Scotland

Network Rail Infrastructure Limited

Dine Scotland Limited

Pensions Tier 3

Having a 'breadth of expertise' in scheme de-risking and corporate support work, Dentons routinely advises on funding matters, equality compliance and buy-outs alongside pension law matters arising from mergers and acquisitions. The 'very pragmatic' team also handles contentious work and is led by the 'dynamic and engagingDavid Knox, who divides his time between Edinburgh and London.

Practice head(s):

David Knox


Excellent collaboration and communication within different areas of expertise and hierarchy across the firm.’

Good communication with the client.

Key clients

Babcock & Wilcox UK

Barnado’s Pension Scheme Members

Barry Callebaut Belgium

Emmaus UK


W.L. Gore

Highland Distillers


MSA Trustees

Personal tax, trusts and executries Tier 3

Dentons, which during 2018 recruited BTO Solicitors LLP's private client head Roddy Harrison, primarily acts for executors in estate administrations and for trustees in the winding up of trusts and restructuring matters, where tax expenses are a central consideration. The team has strength advising on all forms of tax and tax mitigation options, including inheritance tax, entrepreneurs’ relief and business property relief, as well as the impact of the legislative changes to inheritance tax in 2017 that increased the threshold for tax-free assets. Eleanor Kerr advises a number of high net worth clients on succession, asset protection and the tax-efficient structuring of wills.

Practice head(s):

Eleanor Kerr

Other key lawyers:


“A high calibre team, with particular strength in estate planning.” 

“The team is very professional and specialist in their field.” 

“Eleanor Kerr and Alexis Graham stand out, not only for their technical knowledge and expertise but also for the manner in which this is put across at client meetings.” 

“Eleanor Kerr is hugely experienced and explains complex matters to clients in a very easy manner which relaxes clients and helps them to understand their options and come to logical conclusions.”

Corporate and commercial: elsewhere in Scotland Tier 4

Dentons' Aberdeen corporate team is active in the food and drink, financial services, industrial and retail sectors under the leadership of Gordon Hobkirk. The team's junior ranks were recently bolstered by the promotion to senior associate of Nicola Rae, while the oil and gas offering was significantly enhanced by the arrival of counsel Kenny Paton who was previously with Webber Wentzel in South Africa.

Practice head(s):

Brian Moore (Edinburgh)

Other key lawyers:

Key clients

Stork Technical Services (RBG) Limited

Muirden Energy LLP/Duncan Farms

Aberdeen Sports Village

Streamline Shipping Group Limited

The European Marine Energy Group

Decom North Sea

Grieg Seafood Shetland Limited )

The Deeside Water Company Limited

Fearnley Procter Group Limited

Hutcheon Services Limited

Health and safety Tier 4

With particular expertise in the food and drink, retail, oil and gas and rail transportation sectors, Malcolm Gunnyeon's 'pragmatic' team at Dentons provides its clients with health and safety compliance advice and represents them in investigations.

Practice head(s):

Malcolm Gunnyeon


Very good understanding of applicable regulations.

Malcolm Gunnyeon displays all the qualities that one would want when faced with a potential problem; he is calm and has a great breadth of knowledge and experience.

Malcolm Gunnyeon has a fearsome intellect.’

Key clients

The Edrington Group

John Lewis & Partners

Baxters Food Group

Avis Budget

HC One

The Action Group


Menzies Distribution

Zenith Bank (UK)

Holland & Barrett Retail

Planning Tier 4

Primarily acting for developers as well as commercial and housebuilder clients, Dentons is regularly instructed to assist with planning agreements, compulsory purchase issues and judicial reviews, and provide strategic development advice. Stephen Ashworth and Roy Pinnock co-head the team from London following Gillian Simpson's retirement in March 2019.

Practice head(s):

Stephen Ashworth; Roy Pinnock

Other key lawyers:

Fiona Gordon

Key clients

Avant (Homes) Scotland

Robertson Regeneration

Union Square Developments

The Prudential/ M&G Real Estate

Persimmon Homes

Barratt Homes

Aberdeen Standard Investments

Peel Retail Developments

CALA Homes/ Lynch Homes

JD Wetherspoon

Professional negligence Tier 4

Dentons acts for both pursuers and defenders on a variety of claims concerning solicitors and financial services experts. The practice, which benefits from its appointment to the Law Society of Scotland’s Pursuers’ Advisory Panel, is led by Tim Edward, who advises some of the leading insurers in the market.

Practice head(s):

Tim Edward

Key clients

Zurich Insurance

Aviva Insurance

Rieuneau Avocats

Cousin Biotech SA

Beazley Insurance

Photo Name Position Profile
 Claire Armstrong  photo Claire Armstrong Claire is a partner in the Firm’s Asset Management practice, dividing her…
 Allan Cairns  photo Allan Cairns Allan is a Partner in the Real Estate practice and is based…
 David Cruickshank  photo David Cruickshank David Cruickshank is a Partner in the firm’s Public Procurement practice. He…
 Tim Edward  photo Tim Edward Tim is a partner and a member of our Litigation and Dispute…
 Bill Fowler  photo Bill Fowler Bill is a Corporate partner in our Edinburgh office. He specializes in…
 Gareth Hale  photo Gareth Hale Gareth is a partner in the Litigation and Dispute Resolution team, having…
 Susan Kelly  photo Susan Kelly Susan joined Dentons (formerly MMS) in 1991 and was assumed as a…
 Michael Livingston  photo Michael Livingston Partner specialising in all aspects of corporate, financial services banking and insurance…
 Stewart Maciver  photo Stewart Maciver Stewart is a Partner in the firm’s Infrastructure and PPP department. He…
 David McGrory  photo David McGrory David is a partner in the Corporate practice who splits his time…
 Brian Hugh Moore  photo Brian Hugh Moore Brian is a Corporate partner in the Firm’s Edinburgh office and has…
 Catriona Munro  photo Catriona Munro Before joining the Firm in 1998, Catriona worked in Brussels and London.…
 Kirsti Olson  photo Kirsti Olson Dual-qualified in Scotland and England, Kirsti is a construction dispute resolution lawyer…
 Andrew Orr  photo Andrew Orr Andrew is a partner in the Firm’s Infrastructure and PPP department. Andrew…
 Euan Wilson  photo Euan Wilson Euan is a partner in the Infrastructure team with 23 years’ experience…
 James Wilson  photo James Wilson James is a partner in the Banking and Finance team based in…

The Lex 100 Verdict

'A global presence, an ambitious strategy and an excellent and diverse trainee intake' are the best things about Dentons according to the current cohort. The international firm, which offers training contracts in Milton Keynes, Watford, London and across Scotland, is 'strong in a number of fields', with particular expertise in banking law and a notable energy practice. Respondents were impressed that 'partners and superiors are understanding that we are trainees and still learning' and as such are 'willing to teach'. To facilitate their development, recruits are 'given a lot of autonomy to run matters, manage parts of large deals and liaise with high-profile clients directly'. Moreover, despite 'continuing to grow', Dentons has 'retained its people-focused culture' and the environment is 'friendly and non-pretentious' where 'everyone seems to genuinely enjoy coming to work'. Gripes included that there are fewer international secondments than the firm's marketing might have suggested and that the London office 'could use a refurb'. Long hours were also begrudged, with instances of 'working a 90-hour week', 'having two completions two days in a row' and 'repetitive late hours in the corporate department' not uncommon. On the upside, colleagues do not shy away from giving trainees the recognition they deserve for their hard work. 'Receiving exceedingly positive feedback on a deal I had worked on', 'high-level praise from a partner for numerous pieces of work' and an 'excellent appraisal' were but some of the ways in which trainees felt appreciated. Client secondments, which help to 'develop commercial awareness and build client relationships', are also applauded. To work for 'really knowledgeable clients on interesting deals' at an 'incredibly international firm' where you will receive 'varied work and responsibility early on', research Dentons.

Dentons secures final victory for ICT on European patent infringement case against ESSITY

Global law firm Dentons is pleased to announce that the Paris Court of Appeal, the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe and the Barcelona Provincial Court have all issued final decisions dismissing Essity’s claims of patent infringement in regards to Industrie Cartarie Tronchetti’s (ICT) three ply toilet paper. With Dentons’ counsel, ICT successfully demonstrated beyond a doubt that its branded and private label products are produced based on its own proprietary process, and patented under European patent 2 353 859. 

Dentons has been advising Industrie Cartarie Tronchetti S.p.A since 2016. Based in Lucca, ICT is a leader in the category of high quality tissue paper products for domestic use, and has subsidiaries in Italy, Spain, Germany, France and Poland.

The Paris decision, which is the most recent, ends a long-running patent infringement litigation with Essity and affirms ICT can continue to produce and distribute absorbent paper based on its own proprietary technology. The three courts in France, Germany, and Spain have confirmed ICT’s argument that it is using its own novel technology, also patented. Essity’s claims of infringement were based on a patent originally filed by Georgia Pacific, and subsequently becoming Essity’s.

Dentons partner David Masson served as lead partner and represented ICT in France. Dentons partner Dr. Constantin Rehaag represented ICT in Germany, and PwC partner Alejandra Matas Brancós represented the client in Spain, with the support of Dentons partner Juan Ignacio Alonso.

David Masson, lead lawyer on the case, commented: “It has been very interesting to understand ICT’s own technology and work closely with different teams, including ICT’s R&D department, which has been part of all strategic and technical decisions throughout the case”.

Constantin Rehaag, who represented the client in the German court hearings and coordinated the work with the client’s patent attorneys, said: “This is an outstanding success of a great team formed by the client, who provided us with invaluable technological insight, the team of patent attorneys and, finally, by the Dentons teams in France, Spain and Germany.”

The patent litigation began in 2016 when Essity sued ICT in France, Germany and Spain for the alleged infringement of its patent related to the technical solution for the bonding of three layers of tissue for paper products such as high quality, soft and bulky, toilet paper.

In France, Essity claimed that ICT had breached the French part of its European patent 1 081 284 and that the toilet paper marketed as Foxy Soie Plus, and also certain other private labels produced by ICT France, had infringed on their patent. Essity demanded that all production operations be halted. The rolls of toilet paper were carefully analyzed and there were no findings of infringement. The two French courts - in first instance and appeal - rejected the claims and ordered Essity to pay compensation for the legal fees to ICT Italy and ICT France.

In Germany, the case was first taken to the Mannheim District Court, which is well reputed in patent matters. The lawsuit mainly focused on the complex questions regarding the construing of the claims of Essity’s patent. The court ruled in favour of ICT, and Essity filed an appeal. In August 2019, the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe also ruled that the German subsidiary of ICT did not infringe the German part of the patent 1 081 284.

In Spain, after a first decision in favor of Essity in the lower court, the Barcelona Provincial Court clearly stated in a written appeal that ICT’s products - and in particular, Foxy Seda, Foxy Bouquet, certain three-ply private label products - did not infringe the Spanish part of the patent 1 081 284.

About ICT

Industrie Cartarie Tronchetti (ICT) was founded in 1976 in Italy, in the Lucca province, to operate in the tissue sector, producing high quality paper exclusively from virgin fibre. The first production facility was opened in 1978 in Piano della Rocca, Lucca, and over the years new plants and facilities have been set up in Piano della Rocca, Diecimo and Piano di Coreglia. The Foxy brand, one of the leading brands in the European market, was launched in 1982. ICT is an example of excellence in the paper industry, in full harmony with the tradition of the Lucca region, where the most important Italian papermaking hub is located, on a par with those of Green Bay (USA) and Fuji (Japan). In Lucca in particular, great expertise has been nurtured in the field of paper for household use, and the city is in fact known as the world tissue capital. Today, ICT SpA boasts an annual production capacity of about 160,000 tonnes.

About Dentons

Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.

Dentons advises Snam on US$10.1 billion consortium investment in ADNOC Gas Pipelines

Global law firm Dentons advised Italian-based multinational energy infrastructure operator Snam in relation to its agreement, in consortium with several international investment funds, to purchase a 49 percent share of ADNOC Gas Pipelines from The Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC). ADNOC Gas Pipelines is valued at approximately US$20.7 billion (US$10.1 billion for 49%).

The transaction is one of the most important in the global energy infrastructure sector, as well as Snam’s first acquisition outside Europe.  ADNOC Gas Pipelines holds the tariff-based rights for the 38 pipelines that connect ADNOC’s upstream activities to Abu Dhabi’s consumption points and the export and interconnection terminals to neighboring Emirates.

The transaction was financed by a pool of international banks for approximately $8 billion, plus an equity contribution from each of the consortium members.  In addition to Snam, the other consortium members included Global Infrastructure Partners, Brookfield Asset Management, GIC, Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan, and NH Investment & Securities.

Dentons acted with a cross-border team from Italy and UAE, coordinated by partner Sara Biglieri in Milan.  Partners Luca Pocobelli (Rome) and Mhairi Main Garcia (Dubai), counsel Claudio Segna (Milan), senior associate Craig Hughson (Abu Dhabi) and associate Stephanie Hawes (Dubai) advised on corporate and M&A aspects. Partners Alessandro Fosco Fagotto (Milan) and Stephen Knight (Abu Dhabi), counsel Franco Gialloreti, senior associate Tommaso Zanirato and junior associate Giulia Caselli Maldonado (all Milan) advised on financing aspects. Partner Michele Carpagnano (Rome) and associate Giulia Giordano (Rome) advised on the competition and antitrust aspects.

Snam’s internal legal team was led by General Counsel, Marco Reggiani - assisted by Michela Schizzi, Senior Vice President Regulated Assets Legal Affairs - and included senior legal counsels Rosanna Pallotta and Claudia Jolanda Fanelli.  The legal aspects related to the financing were handled, together with Marco Reggiani, by Gloria Bertini, Head of Finance and Capital Market Legal Affairs and Roberta Di Mauro, legal counsel.

Dentons advises Investitionsbank Berlin (IBB) on the establishment of the EU Malaria Fund

The EU Malaria Fund was initiated by the kENUP Foundation, a not-for-profit organization promoting research-based innovation with public and societal benefit. The fund is managed by the IBB Group. The target volume of the fund amounts to €280 million, with a first closing of €70 million on June 3, 2020. A Dentons team from Berlin, Frankfurt, Dusseldorf and Munich provided comprehensive advice to IBB Group on the establishment of the EU Malaria Fund. This included the development of the legal and tax conception of the fund, regulatory advice, corporate law support on the setup of the fund, and the negotiation of the financing agreements with the EIB, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and other investors. Berlin-based partner Dirk-Reiner Voss and Frankfurt-based partner Arne Klüwer jointly led the Dentons team, with support from partners Stephan Busch, Matthias Santelmann and senior associates Holger Hölkemeier and Bernd Düsterbeck in Berlin; counsel Verena Etzel and Oda Elmoutaouakil in Frankfurt; partner Axel Schlieter in Dusseldorf, and partner Richard Fagerer in Munich. About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.

Dentons advises on ACS Group’s €500 million NEU-CP Program

Dentons, the world’s largest law firm, has advised Spanish-based multinational construction group, Actividades de Construcción y Servicios, S.A. (ACS), on the renewal of its €500 million Negotiable European Commercial Paper (NEU-CP) Program. The NEU-CP program is registered with the Central Bank of France, with the involvement of BNP Paribas, BRED Banque Populaire, Crédit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank, ING Bank N.V. and Natixis, as dealers for the Notes. Headquartered in Madrid, the ACS Group is a worldwide leader in construction and services. It is currently the only non-financial issuer with a NEU-CP Program registered with the Central Bank of France. Dentons’ Capital Markets group in Madrid advised ACS on all aspects of the transaction. Partner Ignacio Corujo led and coordinated the transaction with the support of junior associate Ana Artola. Ignacio Corujo joined Dentons in January this year to establish and lead the Capital Markets group in Spain. In addition to this most recent deal for ACS, he has closed several high-value debt capital markets deals since his move, including most notably, Grupo Cajamar’s €1 billion issuance of mortgage bonds, as well as Sacyr’s renewal of its €500 million EMTN Program. About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.  

Dentons advises UniCredit on a €450 million secured sustainability-linked financing for Gunvor Gro

Global law firm Dentons has advised UniCredit Bank AG as Mandated Lead Arranger, (Sustainability) Coordinator, Bookrunner, Facility Agent and Security Agent as well as the lenders on a €450 million secured sustainability-linked borrowing base facility agreement with Gunvor Group. Gunvor Group will use the funds to cover the working capital requirements of its Ingolstadt refinery. The innovative financing model is tied to the borrower's achievement of predetermined ESG key performance indicators (Sustainability KPIs) and provides for a sustainability discount or premium in case the company overachieves or underperforms the predefined targets. An independent sustainability auditor will report on the performance of the Sustainability KPIs on an annual basis. The ESG-based scoring of certain key performance indicators provides a unique way for borrowers and lenders to communicate their commitment to sustainability and incentivizes sustainable corporate measures. Participating banks included DZ Bank, KfW IPEX-Bank, Raiffeisen Bank International, Erste Group Bank, Commerzbank, Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, CA Indosuez (Switzerland), Bank of China and First Abu Dhabi Bank. Gunvor Group is one of the world’s largest independent commodities trading houses by turnover, creating logistics solutions that safely and efficiently move physical energy from where it is sourced and stored to where it is demanded. With strategic investments in industrial infrastructure – refineries, pipelines, storage and terminals – Gunvor Group further generates sustainable value across the global supply chain for its customers. UniCredit is one of the pioneers in sustainable loans in the German market. Düsseldorf finance partner Dr. Axel Schlieter fully advised the bank on the drafting and negotiation of the loan agreement. The Dentons team further comprised Julia Heitmann (senior associate, Banking and Finance, Düsseldorf) and Eike Hinrich Pradt (associate, Banking and Finance, Frankfurt). Axel Schlieter is a core member of Dentons’ Sustainable Finance group in Europe and is regularly involved around the topics of issuance of green bonds and on sustainable financing. Advisors to UniCredit: Dentons (Düsseldorf): Dr. Axel Schlieter, (lead partner), Julia Heitmann (senior associate, both banking and finance, Düsseldorf), Eike Hinrich Pradt (associate, banking and finance, Frankfurt am Main) UniCredit inhouse lawyers: Carina Engelhardt, Alexander Strigin, Christian Hentrich About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.

Dentons advises Qair on refinancing of the acquisition of Rzepin and Linowo wind farms in Poland

Dentons’ Banking and Finance practice team advised Qair SAS, Qair International and Qair Polska Sp.z o.o. in connection with the refinancing of two wind farms under operation, Rzepin (58 MW) and Linowo (48 MW). The financing institutions are BNP Paribas and EBRD. The two wind farms are part of Qair’s larger portfolio of almost 200 MW of renewable energy sources, which also includes 93 MW of new capacity from three wind farms – Udanin (50 MW), Parzeczew (9 MW) and Września (9 MW) – and 25 MW of solar photovoltaic. The project was supervised by Mateusz Toczyski, Head of the Europe and Co-Head of the Global Banking and Finance practice, and led by Tomasz Zwoliński, counsel, with assistance from lawyers Klaudia Szymańska-Rutkowska, Katarzyna Mazur, Katarzyna Kaptur and Jakub Walawski. Supporting the Warsaw team were counsel Surbhi Malhotra-Trenkel in Munich and partners Jean-Marc Allix and Olivier Genevois, and associates Djésia Meziani, Philippine de Fouchier and Hugo Casasnovas in Paris. Dentons’ London team consisting of partner Matthew Sapte and associate Annreika Ray advised on the hedging documentation. “We are very pleased and honored to have had this opportunity to assist Qair in yet another wind power project the company has undertaken in Poland,” said Mateusz Toczyski. “We would like to congratulate Qair on this financing and to wish every success with further developments and investments in Poland and elsewhere in the world,” added Tomasz Zwoliński. About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.

Dentons advises Sev.en Energy on aacquisition of US-based Blackhawk Mining

Dentons has advised international energy group Sev.en Energy on its strategic acquisition of US-based metallurgical coal producer Blackhawk Mining, LLC. C. The transaction comes on the heels of Sev.en Energy’s acquisition of a 17% ownership interest in Corsa Coal in May 2020, further reinforcing its access to the metallurgical coal mining industry in the US market. Blackhawk Mining is one of the largest metallurgical coal producers in the US. With annual production capacity of seven to eight million tonnes of metallurgical coal among its five underground and open pit mining complexes in West Virginia and Kentucky, Blackhawk Mining is an important supplier of metallurgical coal both locally and internationally. It also owns three thermal coal mine complexes producing three to four million tonnes per annum. In 2019, Blackhawk Mining had $1bn revenues and $120m EBITDA.   Commenting on the acquisition, Dentons partner Petr Zákoucký, said: “Having worked for Sev.en Energy for many years, I am inspired by their sustained dynamism, and by this bold strategic move, even during these difficult market conditions. We were delighted to have opportunity to play our role in this success.”   Alan Svoboda, Executive Director of Sev.en Energy who leads the Group’s international expansion added: “Once again, the Dentons team exceeded our expectations and delivered the transaction within a tight time frame of less than a month, nailing both the complexity of the deal and challenges created by the current worldwide pandemic. What was really outstanding was the dedication and flexibility that the entire team showed.”   Dentons’ cross-border team was composed of partners Petr Zákoucký (Prague, Energy/M&A), Ilan Katz (New York, M&A), Lee Smith (New York, Finance), Christopher Van Bever (Lexington, Mining) and John Rhine (Evansville, Mining) Robert E. Richards (Chicago, Insolvency), Managing Associate Gregory DiBella (New York, M&A) and Associate Barbora Obračajová (Prague, Energy). Alvarez & Marsal advised Sev.en Energy on financial due diligence and Weir on technical due diligence.   About Sev.en Energy Sev.en Energy owns significant coal and energy production assets in the Czech Republic, the United Kingdom, Australia and the USA. It is the largest private operator of coalmines and conventional power plants in the Czech Republic, and employs more than 3,500 people. In 2019, Sev.en Energy acquired additional power generation assets from Swiss energy group Alpiq and a 50% stake in the multinational energy company – InterGen N.V., which is one of the leading independent power generators with gas-fired power plants in the UK and coal-fired power plants and coal mines in Australia. When pro-forma aggregated with the financial results of InterGen and Alpiq CZ, Sev.en Energy group combined revenues in 2019 were EUR 1,4 billion and EBITDA of EUR 319 million.   About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.

Dentons supports German subsidiaries of the Recylex Group in restructuring

Global law firm Dentons is assisting Weser-Metall GmbH and Harz-Metall GmbH, both subsidiaries of the French-German Recylex Group, with their restructuring through ‘self-administration’ proceedings. In addition, Dentons restructuring lawyers Andreas Ziegenhagen and Dirk Schoene and their team are advising the German management of the Recylex Group within the scope of its self-administration. As a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and the dramatic decline in metal prices, the German subsidiaries of Recylex have each applied for protective shield proceedings under German insolvency law. The aim of the protective shield is to allow the companies to continue their individual restructuring measures and to return to economic stability after the pandemic - if necessary, in a new shareholder structure. Weser-Metall produces about 100,000 tons of lead per year at its headquarters in Nordenham (Lower Saxony), making it the third largest lead smelter and the second largest lead recycler in Europe. Harz-Metall has its headquarters in Oker in the Harz Mountains and is one of the leading European recycling companies for lead and zinc contaminated waste. The Recylex group has a total of eleven operating units and two administrative sites in France and Germany. In addition to the companies supported by Dentons, two other companies in the group, Norzinco GmbH and PPM Pure Metals GmbH, have also submitted applications for protective shield, whilethree other German subsidiaries requested self-administration under creditor protection. The Group's French companies are not affected. Andreas Ziegenhagen, Head of the Europe and German Restructuring practice, said: "With the filing for protective shield proceedings, we are making use of the most restructuring-friendly court proceedings in the interest of all stakeholders of the companies”. Advisor to Harz Metall / Weser Metall / German management of Recylex: Dentons (Berlin): Andreas Ziegenhagen (Partner, Restructuring, Berlin/Frankfurt), Dirk Schoene (Partner), Dr. Jan Seelinger (Counsel), Dr. Benjamin Kurzberg (Counsel), Judith Schmid (Senior Associate), Dr. Jakob Pickartz (Senior Associate), all Restructuring and Insolvency About Dentons Dentons is the world's largest law firm, connecting talent to the world's challenges and opportunities in more than 75 countries. Dentons' legal and business solutions benefit from deep roots in our communities and award-winning advancements in client service, including Nextlaw, Dentons’ innovation and strategic advisory services. Dentons' polycentric and purpose-driven approach, commitment to inclusion and diversity, and world-class talent challenge the status quo to advance client and community interests in the New Dynamic.