11 New Square has a long-standing reputation as a specialist tax set, deliberately maintaining a small but highly skilled team who utilise their expertise to regularly instruct on indirect tax matters for the Big Four and other accountancy firms, as well as City and regional law firms. Jonathan Peacock KC has over 30 years experience providing tax advice to both private and public clients, frequently appearing before the Supreme Court acting for and against the UK government on tax avoidance matters. Hui Ling McCarthy KC represented the Revenue before the Supreme Court in HMRC v Tooth, a test-case dealing with the concept of staleness and what it means for a tax return to contain a deliberate inaccuracy; with HMRC estimating that more than £1bn of tax turned on this question. Junior John Brinsmead-Stockham KC will appear before the FTT in Lyons v HMRC, one of a number of cases concerning the UK residency test and whether a taxpayer ceases to be a resident in the UK for tax purposes.
Tax: VAT and excise in
London Bar11 New Square
Essex Court Chambers
Essex Court Chambers includes experienced members in the field of VAT and indirect tax, with specialist expertise in areas relating to customs duty, environmental tax and restitution work. Roderick Cordara KC represented the claimants, comprising over 350 local authorities and businesses, in the extremely significant Royal Mail Group Litigation before the Court of Appeal; with Cordara KC being successful on cross-appeal and the matter subsequently being decided by the CJEU. Andrew Legg acted in a complex and high value VAT dispute in Saint-Gobain Building Distribution Ltd v HMRC, with the Upper Tribunal ruling that a historical bad debt relief claim approaching £10m could not be made due to a lack of supporting evidence. Edward Brown KC, who has this year taken silk, appeared before the Court of Appeal in News UK v HMRC, the first VAT dispute to concern the supply of electronic copies of newspapers.
Testimonials
Set
‘Excellent set and Counsel always bend over backwards to make themselves available. ’
Clerks
‘Clerks are very efficient and responsive. ’
Monckton Chambers
Monckton Chambers boasts ‘a number of excellent barristers at a senior and junior level’, offering an unrivalled breadth of experience in indirect tax matters; combining VAT expertise with extensive knowledge of EU, human rights and public law. Melanie Hall KC regularly utilises her wealth of knowledge across the tax realm to litigate on emerging and nuanced areas such as cryptocurrency. Valentina Sloane KC is acting for the Swedish drinks maker in Kopparberg and Cider of Sweden v HMRC, a High Court claim against the UK for an alleged breach of EU law concerning post-duty point dilution which could result in subsequent claims worth hundreds of millions. In Devon Waste Management Ltd & Others v HMRC, Hall KC and Brendan McGurk successfully represented HMRC in the significant test-case challenge brought by leading landfill operators who sought repayment of £3bn of allegedly overpaid landfill tax. Peter Mantle represented the appellant in The Royal Opera House Covent Garden Foundation v HMRC, seeing the Upper Tribunal declare that the sale of goods such as ice cream sold during intervals are not includable when recovering VAT input tax associated with production costs.
Testimonials
Set
‘Monckton is a very strong set with a number of fantastic barristers at a senior and junior level. ’
‘They are well known for VAT work and have some outstanding people. ’
‘Monckton Chambers is excellent. The quality, breadth and depth of Counsel at both senior and junior level is reassuringly consistent. ’
‘The set is well known for VAT, customs and excise and its particular expertise in EU law and its application in the indirect tax world. ’
‘There is a great deal of in-depth expertise in the set and we regard them as our go to set for tax work. ’
Clerks
‘Counsel are readily accessible through an efficient and effective team of clerks, John Keegan being a model example of a modern clerk with a thorough knowledge of Counsel’s specialisms and a wonderful ability to work with clients to identify, clarify and satisfy their requirements. ’
Pump Court Tax Chambers
Pump Court Tax Chambers offers specialist knowledge across the gamut of VAT and indirect tax matters, including an increasing focus on reclaim cases, gaming duty, landfill tax and HMRC’s crackdown on abusive VAT schemes. Roger Thomas KC successfully represented the taxpayer before the Supreme Court in Balhousie Holdings Ltd v HMRC, a case which not only had significant implications for the interpretation of the VAT Act but also clarified that the “statutory purpose test” applied to HMRC as much as taxpayers. Rupert Baldry KC and Barbara Belgrano represented the appellant in Jazztel v HMRC, with the Court of Appeal addressing the incompatibility of features of the UK’s stamp duty regime with European legislation. Zizhen Yang acted in Devon Waste Management Ltd & Others v HMRC, a significant decision for the waste management industry following more than a decade of disputes between landfill operators and HMRC regarding the landfill tax. Sadiya Choudhury has developed an impressive specialism in customs and excise duties and was recently appointed to the Attorney General’s A panel.
Testimonials
Set
‘Pump Court Tax Chambers is the leading tax set and we instruct them on many matters of indirect tax. ’
‘Pump Court are a reliable set with all-star performers across al areas. ’
‘The breadth of expertise across Chambers is incredible. ’
‘Pump Court Tax Chambers are the leaders in this field and there is always a suitably experienced Counsel available in relation to whatever specialist advice is needed. ’
Clerks
‘Excellent, they always put us in contact with the right barrister. ’
‘John Poysner is a fantastic clerk who is always professional and friendly. ’
Devereux
With experienced members advising across the entire field of VAT and indirect tax matters, Devereux acts for high-profile companies, professional clients, individual taxpayers as well as the UK government. The set's tax team has been bolstered by the addition of Howard Watkinson from 2 Hare Court, who appeared before the Court of Appeal in Eynsham Cricket Club v HMRC, a complex VAT charity case regarding whether community amateur sports clubs were eligible for zero-rating relief. Barrie Akin acted for the appellant in Mitchell & Bell v HMRC, the Upper Tribunal considering not only a company overclaiming VAT credits in suspicious circumstances but also complicated procedural matters, specifically the exclusion of evidence and disclosure of potentially significant documents. Felicity Cullen KC is a key name at silk level.
GRAY'S INN TAX CHAMBERS
A well-respected tax set, Gray’s Inn Tax Chambers has a strong reputation for its extensive coverage of the indirect tax sector; acting for high-profile private clients and government agencies on complex matters related to VAT, customs and excise duties, landfill and stamp tax and judicial reviews relating to EU VAT law. Nicola Shaw KC has a practice which spans all contentious tax issues, including judicial review and represents clients from the First-Tier Tribunal through to the European Court of Justice. Laurent Sykes KC and Michael Firth represented the claimants in Test Claimants v Royal Mail Group Ltd, the High Court considering whether over 50 years of Royal Mail’s supplies were tax exempt as assumed and whether Royal Mail is an “emanation of the State” for EU law purposes.
Testimonials
Set
‘The best tax set at the Bar. ’
Clerks
‘The clerks are amazing. ’
Temple Tax Chambers
Temple Tax Chambers has an ‘excellent‘ tax offering, covering the range of indirect tax matters and working for significant clients in both the public and private sector. Tim Brown represented the appellant before the First-Tier Tribunal in Tasca Tankers Ltd v HMRC, successfully convincing the court to reject the HMRC’s application to strike out the case on the basis that it had no chance of success; the respondent subsequently received permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal. In Naghshineh v HMRC, Denis Edwards appeared before the Court of Appeal in the first case before senior courts to consider the availability of sideways loss relief for farming losses under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act.
Testimonials
Set
‘Brilliant Chambers, not just providing advice on particular matters but frequent support on training and ad-hoc issues. ’
Clerks
‘Very professional and responsive. ’
‘Claire James is particularly impressive, manages the daily cases very well and always goes the extra mile to respond and assist on matters. ’
39 Essex Chambers
39 Essex Chambers provides a tailored and experienced tax offering, with members active in a broad range of matters across VAT and indirect tax. Timothy Lyons KC is involved in Naghshineh v HMRC, a significant case before the Court of Appeal which will provide a definitive ruling on the interpretation of relevant provisions of the VAT Act. Kelly Stricklin-Coutinho is a senior junior with widely recognised expertise in tax, acting in the full range of disputes including tax tribunals, High Court claims, judicial review and matters with complex EU law crossover.
Testimonials
Clerks
‘Alastair Davidson is exceptional. ’
‘Sheraton Doyle is a very competent clerk. ’
Blackstone Chambers
In the tax space, a number of members Blackstone Chambers members appear from the First-Tier Tribunal through to the Supreme Court and European Court of Justice on the most contentious indirect tax disputes. Sam Grodzinski KC appeared before the Supreme Court in the long-running VAT dispute worth over £1 billion, with Zipvit Ltd v HMRC being one of the last cases to be referred to the CJEU before Brexit. Fellow silk Kieron Beal KC also featured in the Supreme Court, this time in the highly contentious Balhousie Holdings Ltd v HMRC, representing the respondent in an appeal concerning the VAT treatment of a sale and leaseback transaction involving a care home.
Testimonials
Set
‘Blackstone is an outstanding set, full of leading experts. They always have the right person for every issue and they never let you down or leave you hanging. ’
‘A very well-run set of Chambers. ’
Clerks
‘Particular credit should go to the clerks and to the Chambers management team, including Matt Swallow, who is exceptional at managing and developing their commercial relationships. ’
‘The clerks are very responsive and helpful. ’
11 New Square
Essex Court Chambers
Essex Court Chambers includes experienced members in the field of VAT and indirect tax, with specialist expertise in areas relating to customs duty, environmental tax and restitution work. Roderick Cordara KC represented the claimants, comprising over 350 local authorities and businesses, in the extremely significant Royal Mail Group Litigation before the Court of Appeal; with Cordara KC being successful on cross-appeal and the matter subsequently being decided by the CJEU. Andrew Legg acted in a complex and high value VAT dispute in Saint-Gobain Building Distribution Ltd v HMRC, with the Upper Tribunal ruling that a historical bad debt relief claim approaching £10m could not be made due to a lack of supporting evidence. Edward Brown KC, who has this year taken silk, appeared before the Court of Appeal in News UK v HMRC, the first VAT dispute to concern the supply of electronic copies of newspapers.
Testimonials
Set
‘Excellent set and Counsel always bend over backwards to make themselves available. ’
Clerks
‘Clerks are very efficient and responsive. ’
Monckton Chambers
Monckton Chambers boasts ‘a number of excellent barristers at a senior and junior level’, offering an unrivalled breadth of experience in indirect tax matters; combining VAT expertise with extensive knowledge of EU, human rights and public law. Melanie Hall KC regularly utilises her wealth of knowledge across the tax realm to litigate on emerging and nuanced areas such as cryptocurrency. Valentina Sloane KC is acting for the Swedish drinks maker in Kopparberg and Cider of Sweden v HMRC, a High Court claim against the UK for an alleged breach of EU law concerning post-duty point dilution which could result in subsequent claims worth hundreds of millions. In Devon Waste Management Ltd & Others v HMRC, Hall KC and Brendan McGurk successfully represented HMRC in the significant test-case challenge brought by leading landfill operators who sought repayment of £3bn of allegedly overpaid landfill tax. Peter Mantle represented the appellant in The Royal Opera House Covent Garden Foundation v HMRC, seeing the Upper Tribunal declare that the sale of goods such as ice cream sold during intervals are not includable when recovering VAT input tax associated with production costs.
Testimonials
Set
‘Monckton is a very strong set with a number of fantastic barristers at a senior and junior level. ’
‘They are well known for VAT work and have some outstanding people. ’
‘Monckton Chambers is excellent. The quality, breadth and depth of Counsel at both senior and junior level is reassuringly consistent. ’
‘The set is well known for VAT, customs and excise and its particular expertise in EU law and its application in the indirect tax world. ’
‘There is a great deal of in-depth expertise in the set and we regard them as our go to set for tax work. ’
Clerks
‘Counsel are readily accessible through an efficient and effective team of clerks, John Keegan being a model example of a modern clerk with a thorough knowledge of Counsel’s specialisms and a wonderful ability to work with clients to identify, clarify and satisfy their requirements. ’
Pump Court Tax Chambers
Pump Court Tax Chambers offers specialist knowledge across the gamut of VAT and indirect tax matters, including an increasing focus on reclaim cases, gaming duty, landfill tax and HMRC’s crackdown on abusive VAT schemes. Roger Thomas KC successfully represented the taxpayer before the Supreme Court in Balhousie Holdings Ltd v HMRC, a case which not only had significant implications for the interpretation of the VAT Act but also clarified that the “statutory purpose test” applied to HMRC as much as taxpayers. Rupert Baldry KC and Barbara Belgrano represented the appellant in Jazztel v HMRC, with the Court of Appeal addressing the incompatibility of features of the UK’s stamp duty regime with European legislation. Zizhen Yang acted in Devon Waste Management Ltd & Others v HMRC, a significant decision for the waste management industry following more than a decade of disputes between landfill operators and HMRC regarding the landfill tax. Sadiya Choudhury has developed an impressive specialism in customs and excise duties and was recently appointed to the Attorney General’s A panel.
Testimonials
Set
‘Pump Court Tax Chambers is the leading tax set and we instruct them on many matters of indirect tax. ’
‘Pump Court are a reliable set with all-star performers across al areas. ’
‘The breadth of expertise across Chambers is incredible. ’
‘Pump Court Tax Chambers are the leaders in this field and there is always a suitably experienced Counsel available in relation to whatever specialist advice is needed. ’
Clerks
‘Excellent, they always put us in contact with the right barrister. ’
‘John Poysner is a fantastic clerk who is always professional and friendly. ’
Devereux
With experienced members advising across the entire field of VAT and indirect tax matters, Devereux acts for high-profile companies, professional clients, individual taxpayers as well as the UK government. The set's tax team has been bolstered by the addition of Howard Watkinson from 2 Hare Court, who appeared before the Court of Appeal in Eynsham Cricket Club v HMRC, a complex VAT charity case regarding whether community amateur sports clubs were eligible for zero-rating relief. Barrie Akin acted for the appellant in Mitchell & Bell v HMRC, the Upper Tribunal considering not only a company overclaiming VAT credits in suspicious circumstances but also complicated procedural matters, specifically the exclusion of evidence and disclosure of potentially significant documents. Felicity Cullen KC is a key name at silk level.
GRAY'S INN TAX CHAMBERS
A well-respected tax set, Gray’s Inn Tax Chambers has a strong reputation for its extensive coverage of the indirect tax sector; acting for high-profile private clients and government agencies on complex matters related to VAT, customs and excise duties, landfill and stamp tax and judicial reviews relating to EU VAT law. Nicola Shaw KC has a practice which spans all contentious tax issues, including judicial review and represents clients from the First-Tier Tribunal through to the European Court of Justice. Laurent Sykes KC and Michael Firth represented the claimants in Test Claimants v Royal Mail Group Ltd, the High Court considering whether over 50 years of Royal Mail’s supplies were tax exempt as assumed and whether Royal Mail is an “emanation of the State” for EU law purposes.
Testimonials
Set
‘The best tax set at the Bar. ’
Clerks
‘The clerks are amazing. ’
Temple Tax Chambers
Temple Tax Chambers has an ‘excellent‘ tax offering, covering the range of indirect tax matters and working for significant clients in both the public and private sector. Tim Brown represented the appellant before the First-Tier Tribunal in Tasca Tankers Ltd v HMRC, successfully convincing the court to reject the HMRC’s application to strike out the case on the basis that it had no chance of success; the respondent subsequently received permission to appeal to the Upper Tribunal. In Naghshineh v HMRC, Denis Edwards appeared before the Court of Appeal in the first case before senior courts to consider the availability of sideways loss relief for farming losses under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act.
Testimonials
Set
‘Brilliant Chambers, not just providing advice on particular matters but frequent support on training and ad-hoc issues. ’
Clerks
‘Very professional and responsive. ’
‘Claire James is particularly impressive, manages the daily cases very well and always goes the extra mile to respond and assist on matters. ’
39 Essex Chambers
39 Essex Chambers provides a tailored and experienced tax offering, with members active in a broad range of matters across VAT and indirect tax. Timothy Lyons KC is involved in Naghshineh v HMRC, a significant case before the Court of Appeal which will provide a definitive ruling on the interpretation of relevant provisions of the VAT Act. Kelly Stricklin-Coutinho is a senior junior with widely recognised expertise in tax, acting in the full range of disputes including tax tribunals, High Court claims, judicial review and matters with complex EU law crossover.
Testimonials
Clerks
‘Alastair Davidson is exceptional. ’
‘Sheraton Doyle is a very competent clerk. ’
Blackstone Chambers
In the tax space, a number of members Blackstone Chambers members appear from the First-Tier Tribunal through to the Supreme Court and European Court of Justice on the most contentious indirect tax disputes. Sam Grodzinski KC appeared before the Supreme Court in the long-running VAT dispute worth over £1 billion, with Zipvit Ltd v HMRC being one of the last cases to be referred to the CJEU before Brexit. Fellow silk Kieron Beal KC also featured in the Supreme Court, this time in the highly contentious Balhousie Holdings Ltd v HMRC, representing the respondent in an appeal concerning the VAT treatment of a sale and leaseback transaction involving a care home.
Testimonials
Set
‘Blackstone is an outstanding set, full of leading experts. They always have the right person for every issue and they never let you down or leave you hanging. ’
‘A very well-run set of Chambers. ’
Clerks
‘Particular credit should go to the clerks and to the Chambers management team, including Matt Swallow, who is exceptional at managing and developing their commercial relationships. ’
‘The clerks are very responsive and helpful. ’