Recently, the ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional
Responsibility issued Formal Opinion 477, which aims to provide
guidance and clarity to lawyers as they consider what level of
security to give communications with clients. (I was recently
interviewed by Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly on this topic, and you
can read the full article here; please note that the article is behind a
paywall.)
The bottom line? There is no bright-line rule other than, be
careful! The Opinion spends a good deal of time reminding lawyers
what obligations attach in the era of email and technology —
for example, lawyers must be knowledgeable about current
technology, since it is the stock-and-trade of communication
between lawyers and clients, opposing counsel, and lawyers and the
court. But the Opinion does not demand that lawyers encrypt all of
their communications; doing so would not only be practically
unworkable, but would also be unnecessarily time consuming and, for
some,