Possible alternatives for resolution on state sales and use tax
nexus
On April 17, 2018 the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in
South Dakota v. Wayfair Inc. to consider whether the Court
should overturn the dormant Commerce Clause holding of Quill
Corp. v. North Dakota, 504 US 298 (1992).1
The Justices focused on three major issues during oral argument
including: (1) retroactivity, (2) how much contact is necessary to
justify placing the obligation of collecting and remitting state
sales tax on retailers, and (3) the concern that Congress, and not
the judiciary, is the proper government branch to address this
issue.
South Dakota argued that Quill results in (1) a large
loss of sales tax revenue from online retailers who lack physical
presence within the state, and (2) small businesses within the
state, the local brick and mortar businesses, "being harmed
because of the un-level playing field created by Quill,
where out-of-state remote sellers are given a