The Tax Court has ruled in R. Ball for R Ball III by Appt. v.
Commissioner (T.C. Memo. 2013-39) that shareholders in an S
corporation improperly adjusted the basis of their S corporation
stock upon an election to treat the S corporation's wholly
owned subsidiary as a qualified subchapter S subsidiary (QSUB). The
Tax Court rejected the argument that the QSUB election for the
subsidiary corporation resulted in an item of income for the parent
S corporation, and it denied the shareholders' claim to an
increase in S corporation stock basis.
The shareholders owned stock in American Insurance Service Inc.
(AIS), a C corporation. In 1999, the shareholders of AIS
contributed 100% of the AIS stock to a newly formed holding
company, Wind River Investment Corporation (WRIC), in exchange for
100% of WRIC's stock. WRIC then elected to be taxed as an S
corporation for U.S. federal income tax purposes. In 2003, WRIC
elected to treat AIS as a QSUB for U.S. federal income