In determining the Fair Market Value ("FMV") for
income tax purposes, "valuation discounts" are usually
the most contested items when it comes to family-held minority
shares. These typically include, as applicable, (1) minority (lack
of control) discounts, (2) marketability (illiquidity) discounts,
(3) fragmentation (fractional or partial interest) discounts, (4)
holding company (portfolio) discounts and (5) key-person discounts.
The Tax Court of Canada has addressed some of these in Zeller
Estate, 2008 TCC 426. These types of discounts are
discussed in my September, 2004 presentation at the Canadian Tax
Foundation's Annual Conference.
The Canada Revenue Agency's stated policy since 1989
(Information Circular 89-3, paragraphs 32 ff.) has been
that where there is family or group control, no minority discounts
would be permitted — unless the facts would suggest
otherwise.