For taxpayers using the cash basis accounting method,
determining when to deduct accrued bonuses is typically a
straightforward matter - the compensation deduction occurs when the
bonus is paid.
Similarly, accrual basis taxpayers also believed that decision
was simply determined by answering one question: was the amount
earned by year-end and was it paid within 2½ months of
year-end? If so, then the deduction was allowed in the year of
accrual. If the employee later forfeited the bonus, it was
considered a condition subsequent that did not prevent the
deduction in the earlier year. Unfortunately, IRS, in recent
guidance, has made clear that the necessary inquiry is far more
granular. This guidance, discussed below, has forced many taxpayers
to revise their bonus plans and file accounting method changes for
back-year audit protection. Without a change to their bonus plans,
taxpayers may suffer a significant deferral of their year-end bonus
deductions.