In a recent case, the Florida Supreme Court held that an
arbitration covenant contained in a developer's original deed
also bound the second owner. The case serves as a good reminder
that, although a subsequent owner of residential property might not
think to even review the original deed, such a review is necessary
because that original deed may contain provisions that bind
subsequent owners. See Hayslip v. U.S. Home
Corporation, --- So. 3d ---, Case No. SC19-1371 (Fla. Jan. 22,
2022).
In Hayslip, the second owner of a home in a master
planned community asserted a claim against the builder for
allegedly substandard stucco. The builder sought to compel
arbitration based upon a provision set forth in the original deed
that transferred ownership to the home's first owner, as well
as an arbitration provision set forth in the community's
governing documents. The trial court stayed the litigation and
compelled arbitration. Id.