The United States Supreme Court ruled that the United States
government cannot take a citizen's raisins without paying for
them. Horne v. Department of Agriculture, __
US__ (June 22, 2015). Standing alone, the ruling is
unsurprising.
Taking raisins without paying had been occurring for years -
many years - under the Agricultural Marketing Agreement Act of
1937. The Secretary of Agriculture publishes marketing orders
for particular agricultural products with the aim of maintaining
stable markets. Under these orders, a reserve requirement is
established and a group of raisin growers and others in the raisin
business acting as the Raisin Administrative Committee ( the
"RAC") set the percentage allocation of reserves each
year. Reserve raisins are transferred to the
government without compensation. The RAC disposes of
the reserved raisins by gift or sale. The growers retain an
interest in the net proceeds, if any. The Hornes refused to
transfer the reserved