Introduction
Expert appraisers have testified that the proposed development
will not adversely affect values of properties adjacent to this new
development. Nevertheless, the testimony does not seem right to
you. You remember the Great Financial Crisis – what do
appraisers really know? Based upon your common sense
understanding of real estate values and the way real estate markets
really work, you suspect that the development will adversely affect
adjacent property values. Can you be a Doubting Thomas and
conclude that this admissible evidence simply does not persuade
you?
This is one of the questions addressed by the North Carolina
Court of Appeals in the case of Dellinger v. Lincoln
County, 2106WL3894687(July 19, 2016). As explained
by the Court of Appeals, no Doubting Thomases are allowed in
quasi-judicial land use proceedings.