Introduction
On April 8, 2016, we posted a blog regarding the case of
Quality Built Homes, Inc. v. Town of Carthage, ___N.C.
App. ___, 766 S.E. 2d 897 (2015)(unpublished). In this
case, the Court of Appeals had held that the Town of Carthage
(Town) possessed authority to charge "impact fees" for
water and sewer services.
In our April blog post (
see here) we noted that the North Carolina Supreme Court had
accepted Quality Homes case for review. In our view,
Quality Homes was different from prior zoning and
subdivision cases where the North Carolina Supreme Court had
affirmed the North Carolina Court of Appeals' decisions finding
that local governments did not possess authority to impose school
impact fees. We noted that the case involved the business of
water service, an activity very different from regulatory
activities and suggested that this distinction should make a
difference. We were wrong.