Plaintiffs still cannot dial up TCPA claims in New York.
On May 1, 2013, Judge William F. Kuntz, II of the Eastern
District of New York denied a motion to reconsider his earlier
decision dismissing claims arising under the Telephone Consumer
Protection Act and its accompanying rules and regulations for lack
of subject matter jurisdiction. See Bank v. Independence Energy
Grp. LLC. The Bank Court had dismissed the TCPA
claims in reliance on a Second Circuit precedent, which interpreted
the TCPA to bar claims in New York federal court because New York
State's civil procedure rules do not permit statutory class
actions. See Holster III v. Gatco, Inc.
In denying the motion to reconsider, Bank addressed an
issue not covered in its prior decision, and held that the Second
Circuit's Holster III decision was still good law
after the Supreme Court's subsequent decision in Mims v.
Arrow Financial Services, LLC. Mims had held that federal and
state courts have concurrent