Does a data breach of a retailer's payment-card information
automatically confer Article III standing on affected
customers? Is the mere possibility that some criminal element
may use pilfered information to commit future fraud or
identity theft sufficient to confer customers standing to assert a
class action? Are a retailer's customer service efforts
following a data breach – arguably subsequent remedial
measures – proper evidence of the customers'
injury?
These are some of the bedrock questions luxury retailer Neiman
Marcus has asked the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals to consider
en banc following a three judge panel's bombshell
opinion in Remijas v. Neiman Marcus Group. Before
Remijas, the answer to each of these questions –
based on opinions from the Third Circuit and numerous federal
district courts finding a lack of standing in data breach cases
– was unequivocally "No." Remijas,
however, is a potential game changer on several key fronts because
it is